10/31/2026
Been saying this for a while now
A New York appeals court has revived a repair shop's lawsuit against State Farm over a disputed auto repair payment. The shop, Prospect Auto Sales and Repairs, repaired a 2018 Audi Q7 for $19,736.60 after an accident, but State Farm paid $13,188.22. The insurer argued that its payment reflected the prevailing competitive rate, based on its own survey. The appellate court ruled that the insurer's argument was unsubstantiated because it had not provided the survey it relied on, and it reversed an earlier decision that had dismissed the case. The ruling does not establish that State Farm is ultimately liable for the entire difference, but it allows the contract dispute to proceed. The case highlights a recurring conflict between repair shops' actual invoices and insurers' estimates of reasonable repair costs. Should insurers have to show customers and shops the data behind the labor rates they pay?