02/06/2024
Internet signals. As an electronic technician for 20+ years, primarily in wireless communication across multiple platforms, here are my thoughts. There are a lot of devices out there to consider, but basically any of them will work great if you are near a cell phone tower (cellular internet) or have clear skies (satellite internet). But no cellular product will work when mountains block the signals from the towers, and no satellite will work well during a thunderstorm or if blocked by excessive tree branches. Let's address satellite internet first (starlink, direct TV, etc). They depend on a clear signal from the satellite and storm clouds & trees block that signal, sometimes completely. So weather and terrain are the factors that can affect those. Now for cellular internet - it is all about the antennas. Your phone has a tiny antenna inside of it. Hotspots (dedicated ones) have somewhat larger antennas than cell phones. Routers have multiple antennas, with the more antennas generally bragging about more coverage - but if the antenna receiving the signal from the cell tower is inside, it is still getting significantly blocked by the walls of the RV. Then are are systems with exterior mounted antennas for receiving the tower cellular signal. Those are generally the best, and within those you can get good, better or best antennas. For any given antenna, the throughput speed of the router can potentially be the limiting factor, but most system have routers that can easily handle whatever the packaged antennas can bring in. A cellular internet router/receiver will likely require a SIM card with a data plan, and the better router/receivers can handle multiple SIM cards from different carriers and then select the best one. So multiple data plans along with a multi-modem router/receiver and a quality exterior cellular antenna(s) is your best for cellular, and a satellite system with an antenna that can be relocated (starlink on a stand) is best for satellite. If you are remote most of the time, consider a satellite system. If you need more throughput speed and hang out near to towers, a robust cellular internet system will be the strongest/fastest (not so much in the boonies though).